The Car Place: By Robert Bowden

2004 Nissan Maxima 3.5 SE
Range Rover One James Dean One James Dean One James Dean
Cars are rated one (forget it) to four ('bout as good as it gets) James Deans

Traffic light: green GOOD STUFF

    They fixed the flaws!
    Off-road prowess
    Comfort and convenience galore
    Excellent safety features
    Terrific headlights
    Desirable features are standard, not optional

Red light BAD STUFF

    Sucks gas
    Poor placement of seat adjust panels


 Specifications

  • Style: luxury sport utility
  • Engine: 4.4-liter V8
  • Transmission: five-speed automatic
  • Drivetrain: four-wheel drive
  • Horsepower: 282hp @ 5,400 rpm
  • Torque: 325 ft-lbs. @ 3,600 rpm
  • EPA mileage: 12 city/16 highway
  • Weight: 5,666 lb.
  • Base price: $71,585
  • Price as tested: $77,585

  Just the bottom line

I have good news. And it's not that I saved a ton of money on my insurance. No. The good news is that the 2004 Range Rover is the finest sport utility money can buy.

A few years ago, I didn't feel that way. In fact, in a video featuring my review back then, I pounded my hands on the steering wheel and demanded that Ford (owners of Land Rover) fix the many flaws in the Range Rover I had tested.

Range Rovers, I said then, didn't have quirks; they had flaws.

No longer.

Every flaw that demoted the older Range Rover to an also-ran among top-money sport utilities has been corrected. What we have today is a comfortable, safe, utilitarian vehicle. By most considerations, it has no competitor.

Its styling has new touches, but the whole remains recognizable as a Range Rover, with squared off sides and extremities. The headlights and taillights are new, however, looking something like aftermarket add-on products. The light produced by those headlights is a brilliant, light-up-the-night white.

Inside, the 2004 Range Rover is significantly different from older models. The wood trim on the dash is matched in quality only by Jaguar craftsmen, which is to say it's the best in the world. Leather is boldly stitched, and, watch out, the steering wheel is heated for winter comfort.

Power window switches have been moved from the old location on the center console to the doors, where they belong. As might be expected, operation is one-touch down and up for all four windows. They reverse direction automatically if an obstacle is encountered. But the rear windows stop short of opening fully, a potential problem for Beauregard the Wonder Dog if he likes to hang his head out of a window.

The ignition switch is located on the floor, ala Saab. It takes some getting used to, but is actually safer than the usual dashboard right-of-the-steering-column location, where the right knee can strike the protruding key in an accident.

The Range Rover is a tall vehicle, not meant as a performance handler. A driver must climb up slightly to reach the driver's seat, but the view from there is commanding in all directions. To exit, the driver has to slide off the seat; feet will not touch the ground while seated. In doing so, the driver slides over the panel containing the seat adjustment switches, and the test vehicle's panels on both front seats were already loose. Expect them to pop off after a few months of abuse.

Instruments are clean and easily read, day or night. There are enough switches to delight a Boeing 747 pilot, including ones that raise or lower the vehicle, an aid in ascending or descending steep slopes.

Raised fully, the Range Rover has an 11.1-inch ground clearance.

This vehicle's forte is off road, you understand.

If the owner's manor is deep in the woods, reachable only via a one-lane path that frequently floods, well, no problem for the Range Rover. This sport utility is four-wheel-drive, all the time. A five-speed automatic transmission takes care of shifting chores. And there is both a high and low range available.

The V-8 under the long hood produces enough horsepower (282) and torque to keep the Range Rover competitive with lesser vehicles. But it extracts a significant fuel mileage penalty - as if Range Rover owners would care. The EPA estimates are 12 miles per gallon in the city and 16 on the highway. An on-board computer showed that with careful use of the throttle, I returned 16.1 mpg overall, 14.1 in city driving.

Safety features are first-rate. For those in the front, there are air bags for chests, sides and heads. In the rear, air bags protect heads. The inside rear view mirror is photochromatic, meaning it dims when bright lights approach from the rear. Both outside mirrors tilt down when the Range Rover is backing up, and an ultrasonic detector on the rear bumper emits warning beeps to assist in parking. With the touch of a single button, both outside mirrors will fold inward, so the Range Rover can navigate that narrow opening between the trees.

The rear door is divided into two parts. The upper part releases with a press of the remote key button. The smaller bottom piece is released by a button on its top. Cargo room is generous and a panel keeps valuables hidden. Rear seat room was also exceptional for three adults.

An on-board computer and navigation system are standard. The navigation system is based on the GPS system, as all are, but even keeps track of the Range Rover off road.

The audio system is one of the world's best. It's a 570-watt, 15-speaker Harmon/Kardon Logic 7 Surround Sound model that produces superb fidelity at any volume. The trueness of sound is likely more important to monied ears than the earth-shaking bass favored by the young set doomed to deafness in their 40s.

Auto writers drive so many vehicles over the years that most are gladly returned at the end of testing. Only a few are what we call "keepers". This is one of them. If this veteran auto tester could have a garage of cars, the Range Rover would be in there, ready for the Apocalypse. A few years ago, I wouldn't have kept one if it were won in a lottery. The change in Range Rover is so dramatic, the vehicle so improved, that you owe it to yourself to test drive one if your needs can be met by a special vehicle like this.

'nuff said.

Robert C. Bowden signature



Car, rearviewHome, James

© 2003, Robert C. Bowden
Posted 10/13/03